PDA

View Full Version : XS (1000D) vs XSi (450D) - Advice needed



bchreng
07-15-2008, 01:33 PM
Hey guys!

Since its announcement, I've had my eyes on the XSi - so much in fact that I have totally missed the 1000D announcement until today. I'm moving up from a P&S (Canon Powershot SD1000) to an entry level DSLR and was wondering which one would be better suited for me. I don't intend on taking pictures of sporting events, but would like to focus more on scenery, plantlife, statues, toys and the like. Oh and the occasional social gathering with friends and family as well.

With that said, should I go with the XSi or wait for the XS? I figure since I've been waiting this long, another couple months wouldn't hurt. Right now, the cheapest price for the XSi (with lens) I can find is around $760 (USD). I'm guessing, when it's on sale, the XS (with lens) could probably be found for around $600. Right now photography is just a hobby for me and I likely will not use it for anything too professional.

I can't help but wonder though, that as I become more accustomed to what DSLR cameras are capable of and become more appreciative of their features, do you guys think I'd regret choosing an XS over an XSi? On the other hand, I'd hate to spend extra money on features that I'll likely never use. Features like the 9 pt AF vs 7 pt AF, 14 bit vs 12 bit, and spot metering vs no spot metering, seem like they may make a difference later on down the road. Features like the wireless remote support, rubberized grips, 10.1 vs 12.2 MP, and LCD screen size are a little superficial to me and are not of much importance to me.

Thanks in advance!

FLiPMaRC
07-15-2008, 02:14 PM
Why the XSi or XS? If size doesn't matter to you, have you considered the 40D? The price difference between the XSi and 40D (body only) is very minimal.

See this thread: http://www.dcresource.com/forums/showthread.php?t=40020

Gintaras
07-15-2008, 02:22 PM
look XSi vs. 40D and skip XS, IMO Canon introduced XS trying to ride on the tails of Nikon's success with D40 and D60. XS is a shrank version of XSi.

bchreng
07-15-2008, 03:28 PM
Thanks for the quick responses guys! Cost is a concern for me so the cheaper the better. =)

With that said, I don't want a cheap piece-of-you-know-what either. Size isn't that big a concern for me. Between the 40D and the XSi, I'd opt for the XSi because it's $760 shipped (with lens) whereas the 40D is around $880 shipped (without lens). Similarly, for around $650 shipped (with lens) for an XS seems even more tempting.

timmciglobal
08-12-2008, 10:33 PM
Where are you from? If USA newegg has XSI for 699.

Tim

Turn
08-13-2008, 02:18 AM
I'm going to go against everyone and say get the XS because you seem to not need the extra things that the Xsi/40D offer and the kit lens 18-55 (and maybe the 55-250 IS but I rarely see it being used..) seem to cover all your range

I honestly see anything about the XS to be an overkill for you


I'm glad you're not fussed about megapixels or the 12vs14 bit stuff