PDA

View Full Version : Canon S1 IS or Panasonic FZ20?


jhouse01
03-01-2006, 09:57 AM
Hi all,

Oops, edited here to say I meant Canon S2 IS!

My husband and I are both novices, and are buying our first digital camera.

So here's our information:

Uses: nature shots (think birds), general vacation shots, some indoor/low lighting (bands in clubs).

Budget: $300 to $400

Size: not a huge consideration

Features: image stabilization will be important, I don't think we'll be carrying a tripod around--at first anyway. Low lighting capabilities fairly important, ease of use while we learn, also ease of software. Zoom is very important, and we'll likely get a telephoto converter lense down the road.

Image quality: importance on a scale of 1-10, 7 or 8 I should think. We're beginners not pros.

We'll probably be sharing photos on the internet, and getting some prints done outside the home, won't be printing them ourselves.

I'm told shutter lag time is a consideration for animal shots.

Manual controls: Well, we are beginners, so I'm not quite sure about that--as I said, we may grow into it, so I'm not sure how important that will be.

I'm not hugely concerned about the differences in movie mode, though we may come to use that feature a lot--hard to say right now.

From everything I've read & reviews, 2 cameras that sound good are the Canon S1 IS, and the Panasonic FZ20, both of which I've found for under 400.
I'm a little concerned that the telephoto converter lense for the Panasonic is $500, so one question is: can I use a different (less expensive) lense?

My local birding forum people tell me they favor the image stabilization of the Panasonic over the Canon.

The price of batteries/accessories is a consideration.


Thanks--any & all advice greatly appreciated!

J House

tim11
03-01-2006, 04:37 PM
Canon S1 IS? You mean S2 IS?
Tele converter lens for Panasonic is ripped off. However, many Pana owners successfully use 3rd party adapter and converter lens - check out Panasonic forum.

Rhys
03-01-2006, 05:34 PM
Canon S1 IS? You mean S2 IS?
Tele converter lens for Panasonic is ripped off. However, many Pana owners successfully use 3rd party adapter and converter lens - check out Panasonic forum.

Maybe even the S3 IS?

The S1 - 3 megapixels and compact flash
The S2/3 more megapixels and Secure Digital.

tim11
03-01-2006, 06:25 PM
S3 will not fit the budget.

Rhys
03-01-2006, 06:43 PM
S3 will not fit the budget.

OK. My S1 isn't great at night or in low-level lighting. I don't think the S2 is much better. Generally consumer P&S digicams aren't.

Where the S1 really scores is in high-quality video and in telephoto range.

tim11
03-01-2006, 07:37 PM
Rhys. I was thinking S2 instead of S1 because I doubt you can still buy a new S1 from a shop. No other reason than that.

Rhys
03-01-2006, 07:40 PM
Rhys. I was thinking S2 instead of S1 because I doubt you can still buy a new S1 from a shop. No other reason than that.

Fair enough. Go with whatever's available. I just refer to the S1 because it's the version I have.

Although I have a dSLR, I do still use my S1 because it's handy for taking to highschool football matches and plays in which my stepson is performing.